Q: In your experience and in your professional opinion, is charismatic music and the instruments it makes use of suited to a truly Catholic liturgy?
A: No. They are eminently suitable for personal use, or for a prayer meeting or a festival of praise, but they have no place in Catholic liturgy, which is solemn and sacred. If one truly understands the Faith and the liturgy through the Church's eyes, he will see this. As Catholics we believe that the Holy Spirit speaks through the Church, therefore we should be yearning to do what our Mother asks and to love what She loves.
More in this excellent interview with Professor Susan Treacy of Ave Maria University.