Tomorrow, November 21, is the feast of the Presentation of the Blessed Virgin Mary. For liturgical notes on the day, one can do no better than turn to Gregory DiPippo’s reflections. And here are some additional observations.
This feast was first introduced into a Western calendar in 1372 (the Papal Chapel in Avignon, to be precise), but it has been celebrated in the Greek East since at least the seventh century, where it is known as the Entry of the Most Holy Theotokos into the Temple.
An icon of the Entrance of the Mother of God into the Temple, by the Cretan painter Theodore Pulakis (1622-92).
Both titles might give the impression that the feast is commemorating Mary’s entry into the Temple as a new mother in order to present her son Jesus forty days after His birth, in accordance with the Law. That event, however, is celebrated on February 2. Rather, this holy day celebrates when Saints Joachim and Anne presented their daughter Mary to the priests of the Holy Temple in Jerusalem to be consecrated to God and educated in preparation for her divine maternity.
Joachim and Anne, it is said, were a pious and childless elderly couple who prayed to God for a child and who received a positive answer from Heaven. In thanksgiving, they presented their daughter at the age of three to the priests and Levites who ran the temple. Mary, who would have been housed in lodgings on or near the Temple Mount, subsequently received an excellent education in the Law – and, unbeknownst to anyone at the time, this education helped prepare her for saying “Yes” to God when He “proposed” to her through the message of the Angel Gabriel and for the great vocation of being the Mother of Our Lord. The Blessed Virgin stayed in the Temple from the ages of three to twelve, at which point she was betrothed to Saint Joseph.
The story of Our Lady’s presentation is taken from the second-century apocryphal work the Protoevangelium of James and is not a point of doctrine, but it is a good reminder that apocryphal writings, even if they are not 100% inspired by an inerrant Holy Spirit, are not without theological value. And the account is certainly not beyond the realm of possibility. In the Old Testament, Hannah did something similar with her son the prophet Samuel (1 Sam. 1, 1-28). There is evidence of a widespread belief in Our Lady’s Presentation in both the East and the West since at least the fifth century.
Dom Guéranger opines that this feast is providentially timed, coming as it does before Advent. “The mystery of Mary’s sojourn in the sanctuary of the Old Covenant,” he writes, “is our best preparation for the approaching season.” As the “happy completion of all the waiting and supplication for the coming of the Son of God,” Mary’s studies in the Temple, when she poured over the meaning of the Law, is a perfect image for us as we liturgically expect the Messiah.
Fr. Alban Butler draws a moral lesson from this sacred mystery. “By the consecration which the Blessed Virgin made of herself to God in the first use which she made of her reason,” he writes, “we are admonished of the most important and strict obligation which all persons lie under, of an early dedication of themselves to the divine love and service.” “Everyone is bound,” he continues, “in the first moral instant of the use of reason to convert his heart to God by love.” The Presentation of the Blessed Virgin seems to be asking us, why wait to be happy? Start early and often to learn about, love, and adore our merciful Lord God.
St. Jean-Baptiste de La Salle sees the Presentation as the historical fulfilment of the Woman in the Book of Revelation fleeing to the desert, for both the desert and the Temple are places “separated from the usual activities of people.” He also notes the appropriateness of the future Temple of the Lord and sanctuary of the Holy Spirit matriculating at the Holy Temple. Finally, not unlike Butler, La Salle portrays Mary rather than her parents as the principal agent of this event: instead of Anne and Joachim presenting their daughter in the Temple, “the Most Blessed Virgin dedicated herself entirely and without any reservation to God on this holy day,” with her parents merely accompanying her “for this holy action.” I suspect that the Saint’s focus on his own congregation of Christian Brothers, to whom he is writing, affected his interpretation, for he uses the occasion to admonish his brethren:
You have the happiness of being in God’s house, and you are bound there to his service. You must be filled with graces by the holy practice of prayer and strive to practice the virtues that are most fitting to your state. By these holy exercises, you will be able to fulfill your duties well.
Donations are now open, including tax-deductible giving for US readers, and every gift will be matched.
Perhaps readers will remember my earlier post about reordering the sanctuary at St Mary’s Catholic Cathedral in Aberdeen under the patronage of Bishop Hugh Gilbert. I described it then as a model that other Roman Rite churches would do well to study, and I still think so. I am writing about it again because the project is now open to donations from anyone who wishes to support it, including readers in the United States who want their gift to be tax-deductible.
I believe there is a crisis of imagery in the Roman Rite. The Byzantine Churches have a largely standardized arrangement of images in the sanctuary, which draws the worshiper into the mysteries being celebrated. The Roman Church has never had one. Instead, it relied on a general understanding of how imagery conveyed the themes of the liturgy, without mandating much in the way of specifics. When tradition is strong and well understood, this freedom allows for rich variation, and in the past it was a great strength of Catholic culture. Today, however, we are disconnected from that tradition. Few understand how the Church has communicated Eucharistic themes through images, or how to engage with those images in worship. We could ask the Church as an institution to step in and mandate schemas for every church, but that is as likely to stifle creativity as to encourage it.
A better answer, I think, is to create exemplary schemas that others will want to emulate once they see them. The reordering of the sanctuary at St Mary’s is one such project. It is rare to see a commission where the bishop, the artists, the architect and the craftsmen work this closely, and where the theology of the liturgy so clearly governs every decision. The result will serve the people of Aberdeen. It will also, I believe, give many in the wider Church a working example of what a Roman Rite sanctuary can be. Projects like this need patrons. With the matching gift in place, now is the best time to become one.
How to give
The diocese has established a fund with the Chapel & York Foundation called the “RC Diocese of Aberdeen Charitable Trust.” US tax-deductible donations can be made through the online form for Beauty for God here:
Fundraising is going well. Nearly two-thirds of the £685,000 (about $900,000) target has now been pledged or given. One generous donor has offered to match all remaining donations, so every gift will be doubled. A $100 gift becomes $200 for the cathedral.
A mock-up of the final reordering.
Where the project stands
The final sanctuary designs are underway. In early November, Martin Earle will visit the cathedral with full-scale wood and card mock-ups of the new elements: the altar, ambo, cathedra and tabernacle. He will test them in the space itself, and what he learns will inform the final design adjustments. This is how such work ought to be done. A design that looks right on paper has to be proven in the building where people will pray.
More on the east wall painting
Since my first article, Martin has shared his notes on the design of the east wall mural. They add a good deal to what I wrote before, and I think they are worth sharing because they show how carefully every element has been considered.
He starts with four aims. The painting should be beautiful and contemplative, not visually overwhelming. It should be simple, yet unfold over time, so that the viewer keeps discovering meaning on return visits. It should be mystagogical, revealing what happens invisibly when the Word is proclaimed, and the Eucharist is celebrated. And it should speak of life and hope, which is why the landscape is green, recalling the just man of the first psalm, who is “like a tree planted by streams of water” (Ps, 1, 3).
The structure has two levels, the Church on earth and the Church in heaven. Below is Pentecost. Mary stands at the center with the Apostles around her. This connects directly to the crucifix above the altar, especially to the moment when Christ “bowed his head and gave up his spirit” (John 19, 30). The Spirit Christ gives up on the cross is the Spirit poured out on the Church.
Above is the heavenly liturgy. The Lamb stands on the mountain from which flow the rivers of paradise (Apoc. 22, 1; Gen 2, 10-14). Angels minister around him, and the Father’s hand blesses from above. The two levels form a single circle of worship. As the Letter to the Hebrews puts it, “you have come to Mount Zion and to the city of the living God, the heavenly Jerusalem” (Hebr. 12, 22). We do not go to heaven after Mass. At Mass, we are already there.
The prophets occupy the middle level. Isaiah receives the burning coal on his lips (Isa 6, 6-8). This purification prefigures both Pentecost and the Eucharist. It is also the vision in which the seraphim cry “Holy, Holy, Holy,” words we take up in the Sanctus at every Mass. Ezekiel is given the scroll to eat (2, 8 – 3, 3), the Word he must then proclaim. Both prophets, having received, are sent out. In this they prefigure the dismissal at the end of Mass: Ite, missa est.
On the lower level, St Paul stands on the left and St John on the right. They carry the prophetic mission forward after Pentecost. The entrance antiphon for the feasts of the Apostles comes to mind: “Their voice has gone out through all the earth” (cf. Ps. 18, 4). Through their preaching, the earth is made a paradise. Martin links them visually to the prophets above: Paul to Isaiah and John to Ezekiel. Both Apostles look through Mary. This expresses how the Church reads the Old Testament through the Incarnation, as Christ himself did on the road to Emmaus, “beginning with Moses and all the prophets” (Luke 24, 27).
The rivers tie the whole together. They flow down from the heavenly mountain, and two of them run through the books the Apostles hold: the Torah in Paul’s hands and the scroll John is writing. This is the Word of God carrying heavenly grace down to nourish the faithful. Below, the lambs, representing the Apostles, process toward the tabernacle, as in so many early Christian mosaics.
Martin also considered the visual connections the color scheme can create. Blue links Mary, the tabernacle, the rivers of paradise, and the heavenly sphere. Green signifies new life, the “green pastures” of Psalm 23 and Psalm 1, as mentioned before. The clouds around the rose window are painted to evoke dawn light. This is an eschatological image: the Church, in prayer, facing east, awaiting Christ's return.
BRING BEAUTIFUL LITURGY AND SACRED MUSIC TO EVERY PARISH!
From Fr. Robert Pasley, President of the CMAA
Thank you for reading the New Liturgical Movement! In support of NLM and its mother organization, the Church Music Association of America (CMAA), would you please give now to our Feast of St. Cecilia (Nov 22) annual fundraising drive?
The important work of NLM is only made possible because of the CMAA. When you give to the CMAA today, you share the work of the NLM and the Church’s rich liturgical tradition!
If you believe the presence of Christ is most fully revealed in the sacred liturgy when it is celebrated solemnly, with sacred music the Church sees as its own, with each person worshipping God and each musician rendering their greatest musical capacity . . . then please consider giving to the CMAA today!
When you support the CMAA, you invite the clergy and the faithful to discover the Church’s treasury of sacred music – Gregorian chant, sacred polyphony, organ music, and worthy new compositions. You equip them through education, and you build friendships and collegiality that enable musicians to flourish through a life of service in the Church.
CMAA invites you to play a critical role in the longest standing sacred music society in the United States, established to teach and implement the Church’s treasury of sacred music in the context of the sacred liturgy.
When you support the CMAA today, you help bring sacred music to every parish! I ask you, therefore, to please help during this Feast of Saint Cecilia fundraising drive. Please make a donation by Sunday November 22.
I have been a CMAA member for over 44 years. I am a volunteer as the president. I think the organization is so important, that I have donated $1,000 to the cause. I don’t say this to brag, but to let you know that I am one with you in supporting this great organization. Could you match my donation, or double it, or even multiply it by ten? Every donation would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!
It is very fitting that the feast of St Gertrude the Great should begin the second half of the month of November, during which the Church encourages us to pray more fervently for the dead as we near the end of the liturgical year. As the Divine Office notes, she was especially devoted to prayer for the souls in purgatory: “With daily acts of assistance and with prayers, she helped the souls of the just given over to the purifying flames.” From this comes also the famous prayer for the dead attributed to her: “Eternal Father, I offer you the Most Precious Blood of your Divine Son, Jesus, in union with the Masses said throughout the world today, for all the Holy Souls in Purgatory, for sinners everywhere, for sinners in the universal Church, for those in my own home and in my family. Amen.”
St Gertrude, 1763, by the Mexican painter Miguel Cabrera (1695-1768). Public domain image from Wikimedia Commons.
Here are some excerpts from the collected accounts of the many visions vouchsafed to St Gertude, which are especially pertinent to praying for the dead.
Another religious died soon after, who from her infancy had been specially devoted to the Mother of God. After she had received the last Sacraments, and when she appeared almost dead, she gave singular edification to the religious by the affection and compunction with which she kissed the wounds of a crucifix which was presented to her, addressing it in the tenderest words. After pouring forth the most ardent and fervent prayers for pardon of her sins, for the protection of her Spouse in her last moments, and for the assistance of the Blessed Virgin, the Angels, and Saints, her strength failed, and she passed, as in a quiet sleep, to her eternal reward. As the community were reciting the usual prayers for the repose of her soul, our Lord appeared to a religious with the deceased in His arms, saying to her affectionately, “Do you know Me, My child?” Then she who was favored with this vision prayed that our Lord would specially reward that soul for her humble and efficacious charity in having served her on many occasions, and for having been especially earnest in doing service to those religious who were most holy and devoted to God, in order that she might share in their merits and graces. Our Lord therefore presented His deified Heart to her, saying, “Drink freely from Me a reward for all which thou didst when on earth for My elect.”
On the following day, at Mass, the soul appeared as if seated in our Lord’s bosom, and His Blessed Mother appeared to give joy to this soul by a communication of her merits. This was specially the case while the community recited the Psalter for her, with the Ave Maria; so that at each word, the Mother of our Lord appeared to make presents to this soul, who received them to increase her merit before God. …
At the Mass, when they sung at the offertory Hostias ac preces, our Lord elevated His right hand, and shed forth from it a marvelous light, which illuminated the whole heaven, but especially this soul, which was in the bosom of our Lord. Then the Saints approached, each according to their rank, and placed their merits as an offering on the breast of Jesus, to supply for the deficiencies of this soul. The religious knew that they acted thus because, when that soul was on earth, she had been accustomed to pray that the Saints would give this assistance to the souls of the deceased. The Saints then testified to their affection for her by endeavoring to increase her happiness, and the virgins embraced her specially, as having in common with them the excellent grace of virginity.
ON one occasion, while Mass was celebrating for a poor woman who had died lately, St. Gertrude recited five Pater nosters in honor of our Lord’s Five Wounds for the repose of her soul; and, moved by divine inspiration, she offered all her good works for the increase of the beatitude of this person. When she had made this offering, she immediately beheld the soul in heaven, in the place destined for her; and the throne prepared for her was elevated as far above the place where she had been, as the highest throne of the seraphim is above that of the lowest angel. The Saint then asked our Lord how this soul had been worthy to obtain such advantage from her prayers, and He replied: “She has merited this grace in three ways: first, because she always had a sincere will and perfect desire of serving Me in religion, if it had been possible; secondly, because she especially loved all religious and all good people; thirdly, because she was always ready to honour Me by performing any service she could for them.” He added: “By the sublime rank to which she is elevated, you may judge how agreeable these practices are to Me.”
ON Rogation Wednesday, at the elevation of the Host, she besought our Lord for the souls of the faithful in purgatory, that He would free them from their pains by virtue of His admirable Ascension; and she beheld our Lord descending into purgatory with a golden rod in His Hand, which had as many hooks as there had been prayers for their souls, by which He appeared to draw them into a place of repose. She understood by this, that whenever anyone prays generally, from a motive of charity, for the souls in purgatory, the greater part of those who, during their lives, have exercised themselves in works of charity, are released.
Continuing with the photos taken by a friend during his recent visit to Armenia, here we have a few items from the Mesrop Mashtots Institute of Ancient Manuscripts in Yerevan, the capital city. This research institute holds the largest collection of Armenian manuscripts (and many other kinds of items) in the world, largely nationalized (i.e. stolen) from the Church. St Mesrop (362-440), for whom the institute is named, was a priest and monk who invented the Armenian alphabet and laid the foundations of the nation’s entire literary tradition; a statue of him is placed outside the main building.
A Gospel book of the 13th century, made in Cicilia, the southeast coastal region of Asia Minor. In the late 11th century, many Armenian fled to this region when their native land was invaded by the Seljuk Turks, such that it came to be known as Lesser Armenia.
Illustrations of the Annunciation and Nativity of Christ from another Gospel book.
A metal cover for a Gospel book.
The Targmanchats Gospel book, dated to 1232, decorated by two artists who were both named Gregory. This is a very common named among Armenians, after the Saint who evangelized them at the beginning of the 4th century, Gregory the Illuminator.
A copy made for display purposes of an ivory cover for a Gospel book; the original was made in the 6th century.
The following is taken from the entry on All Souls’ Day in William Durandus’ Rationale Divinorum Officiorum (7.35), the Summa Theologiae of medieval liturgical commentaries. This is one of the longest sections of the seventh book, which covers the Sanctoral cycle, and is being presented in several parts over the course of this month especially dedicated to prayer for the dead; click here to read part 1 and part 2. On four occasions, Durandus refers his reader to other parts of the Rationale where he has already explained something; the reference numbers to these are given in red at the beginning of the relevant paragraphs.
The Office of the Dead imitates the three days of Christ’s burial in every way, for just as on the Triduum, so also in this Office we omit all the songs of praise, and take away all the signs of solemnity. In the Mass, we do not ask for blessings from the bishop (or priest), and in the Office, we do not say “Lord, thou shalt open my lips”, nor “God, come to my assistance” nor “Let us bless the Lord”, nor even the invitatory (unless the body is present), nor “Glory be to the Father” at the responsories and the end of the Psalms, nor do we ask for or give a blessing at the lessons, nor do we say “Tu autem, Domine” or “Thanks be to God”; in the Mass, we do not say Alleluja, nor the Gloria in excelsis, nor Ite, Missa est. For in the old Law it was prohibited to offer the oil of rejoicing and the incense of sweetness for sin. Death is the avenging of sin, and for this reason, where there is sin, there is also darkness, nor should there be rejoicing or the singing of the joyful songs where there is mourning and sadness of the spirit, and funeral rites are celebrated for the dead with mourning.
Again, we suppress praises because, not knowing where the dead go, we do not know whether we ought to praise God for his justice or his mercy; we suppress joy because we enter into this world with sadness, and go out of it with greater sadness. Therefore, a Sequence also ought not to be said, since it is the song of rejoicing. (Durandus wrote this before the universal adoption of the Dies irae into the Requiem Mass.)
Furthermore, although in a Mass for the living all should be incensed, to signify that their prayers are directed towards heaven, nevertheless, in the Mass for the dead, the altar and the choir incense should not to be incensed, but only the body… Therefore no one is incensed in this service, to signify the dead can no longer merit anything by their praises, whence the psalmist says (113, 25), “the dead shall not praise thee, o Lord.”
The bodies of the dead are incensed and sprinkled with blessed water, not so that their sins may be taken away, which at that point cannot be taken away for such things, but so that all presence of unclean spirits maybe warded off. These things are also done as a sign of the society and communion of the sacraments which they had with us while they were alive. For this reason also, Denis (the Areopagite) tells that in ancient times, the living would kiss the dead as a sign of the unity which they had with them. These things and others like them benefit them to the degree that through such things, reverence is offered to God himself.
6.52.2 At the Introit of the dead Requiem aeternam, two verses are said, because we pray for the dead, asking that they be given rest of both body and soul. The second verse is said in place of “Glory be to the Father…”, which is omitted in the Office of the Dead, since the dead can no longer praise the Trinity…
4.15.16 In Masses for the dead, the collect for the living, as it is called, should not be added, not even the common one composed by Augustine, “God, who rulest over the living and the dead”, to signify that the dead cannot help the living in this life, not even to implore eternal life (for them)…
The Peace is not given for three reasons. The first is that this service … follows the three days of Christ’s burial, when the Peace is not given in detestation of Judas’ kiss. Second, because we have no communication with the dead, since they cannot answer us… This is the reason why a body should never be in the church as long as the Mass of the day is being celebrated. Indeed, if it were there before, it ought to be taken outside the church into the vestibule, however great the authority of the deceased was while they were living, and afterwards be brought back in for the Mass for the dead.
The third is that just as one bread is made as from many grains gathered together, and one wine is distilled from many clusters of grapes, so also the one Church is built and united from many faithful, some of whom are good and some bad. Therefore, because we do not know whether a dead man is in union with the Church and has peace and reconciliation with his Creator, we do not give the Peace at Mass, nor do we bring forth any praises for the dead, … for their rest is not yet apparent.
4.53.8 In the Mass for the dead the peace is not given, because the faithful souls are no longer in the tribulation of this world, and never will be again, but are already resting in the Lord; and for this reason, the kiss, which is the sign of peace and harmony, is not necessary for them. For the same reason, in that Mass the prayer, “Lord Jesus Christ who gave peace to your apostles” is not said, nor does the priest receive the peace from the altar. … this is also the reason why among monks the peace is not given, since they are counted as being dead to the world.
… the Office of the Dead begins with Vespers, after which follow the vigils, which are of three kinds. In some churches, nine readings are done from Job… in others, they are taken from the book of Wisdom … but in others from a sermon of Augustine. But wherever they are taken from, they begin without a title or blessing, and without “Tu autem, Domine”, following the custom which is observed in the funeral rites which we celebrate for Christ on the Triduum. But in some churches, in place of “Tu autem, Domine”, the readings end with “Blessed are the dead who die in the Lord,” from the book of the Apocalypse (14, 13).
The readings described below in a breviary according to the Use of Bamberg, printed in 1501.
“From the book of Wisdom” – Durandus is here referring to a set of brief readings which some churches had for the daily celebration of the Office of the Dead, the first three of which are taken from the books of Wisdom. (Proverbs 5, 9-11; Ecclesiastes 7, 2-3; ibid. 12, 1 and 7). The next three, however, are from the Prophets (Isaiah 26, 19; Hosea 13, 14-15; Daniel 12, 2-3), and the last three from the New Testament (1 Corinthians 15, 22-23; ibid. 51-52; 1 Thessalonians 5, 2-5 and Apocalypse 14, 13).
The Psalm “A hymn becometh Thee, o God” (64), is frequently said in this service, because it treats of the return of the sons of Israel from captivity to the promised land; so also the dead go from the misery of captivity to eternal life. …
5.9.10 The Office of the dead … does not have second Vespers, to signify that it will have an end, and the souls of those who shall be saved, delivered from every pain, shall enjoy eternal blessedness.
At the council of Toledo, it was established that a priest who celebrates Mass for the dead so that his enemy may meet his death should be deposed, and both he and the one who incited him to do this should be punished with perpetual exile.
Applications for Summer 2027 at the Catholic Institute of Sacred Music (CISM) are now open. CISM offers a rich learning experience for parish and school musicians who want to immerse themselves in the beauty, truth, and holiness of the Church’s sacred music and liturgy. The Institute offers a daily schedule of sung liturgies on campus and opportunities for private prayer, a world-class faculty, dormitory rooms and common meals on a beautiful campus in the temperate climate of Silicon Valley, and opportunities for study in subjects that are inspiring, challenging, and practical.
Whether you’re new to sacred music or have studied music at the graduate level, our courses will assist you in unlocking the treasury of Catholic sacred music, helping you grow in your spiritual life, amplifying your knowledge of and love for Christ and the Church’s music, and strengthening the skills needed for faithful service in the Church.
Join us this summer to experience the depths of the Church’s riches, taught by experienced teachers and musicians, faithful to the Church’s magisterium and tradition.
This summer’s line-up of classes features interesting new seminar topics, fantastic core classes offered for the first time, and foundational classes which offer intellectual, musical and spiritual growth.
History & Principles of Sacred Music - taught by Dr. Jennifer Donelson-Nowicka
Fundamental Philosophical Questions about Beauty - taught by Fr. Anselm Ramelow, O.P.
Sacred Music and Canon Law - taught by Fr. Vincent Woo
July 5 to 9, 2027
Vocal Pedagogy - taught by Prof. Sandra Bengochea
Liturgical Theology - taught by Fr. Nicholas Schneider
July 12 to 16, 2027
Introduction to Gregorian Chant - taught by Dr. Jennifer Donelson-Nowicka
Choral Literature Survey II - taught by Prof. Christopher Berry
Choral Repertoire Conducting Practicum II - taught by Profs. Christopher Berry and Martin Baker
July 19 to 23, 2027
Choral Institute - taught by Prof. Christopher Berry and Dr. Jennifer Donelson-Nowicka
Organ Improvisation - taught by Prof. Martin Baker
July 26 to 30, 2027
Choral Preparation: Choral Conducting, Rehearsal Techniques, and Group Vocal Pedagogy - taught by Prof. Christopher Berry
Teaching Gregorian Chant to Children - taught by Dr. Jennifer Donelson-Nowicka
Advanced Seminar in Chant: Byzantine Chant - taught by Dr. Alexander Lingas
Advanced Seminar in Chant: The Gregorian Modes - taught by Dr. Charles Weaver
August 2 to 6, 2027
Advanced Seminar in Gregorian Chant: Hildegard of Bingen in Historical and Liturgical Context - taught by Dr. Alison Altstatt
Advanced Seminar in Gregorian Chant: Approaches to Gregorian Rhythm - taught by Dr. Charles Weaver
Parish Sacred Music Program Management - taught by Dr. Jennifer Donelson-Nowicka
Introduction to the Organ for Pianists - taught by Prof. Christopher Berry
Summer study is embedded in a context of sung Masses and Vespers with time for recreation in the beautiful Northern California region and a wonderful community of scholars and practitioners who are pursuing holiness and musical excellence.
The publisher of NLM and president of our parent organization, the Church Music Association of America, Fr Robert Pasley, is encouraging all our viewers to participate in the CMAA’s effort to promote the use of Gregorian chant, and join the new CMAA Groups initiative. Please share this message with anyone you think might be interested!
A friend shared with me some thoughts about the question of laity imitating the priest in the orans posture, which was once very popular among the faithful, has died down somewhat over the years, and has recently been clamped down on by the Archbishop of Portland. Here’s what he wrote:
Since we have “orans posture discourse” making the rounds yet again, I thought I’d offer some reasons for why this issue arises to begin with.
It is entirely natural for people who are acting with or responding to someone to mimic or mirror their actions. When someone waves or extends a hand, we tend to wave or extend a hand. Hence, when the priest makes the Sign of the Cross in blessing, he does it with his hand away from his body, symbolizing that it’s being given (or ‘sent’), and in response the faithful make the Sign of the Cross touching their body, symbolizing their reception of it. In the Eastern Church they take this one step further: the priest makes the Sign of the Cross in blessing the ‘regular way’ (towards his left first, then his right), and the faithful in response make it the opposite way (right shoulder, then left shoulder), in a literal mirror image of his action.
Most of the actions of the faithful during the Mass (both Novus Ordo and TLM) can be boiled down to ‘responding’ to the priest’s actions, not ‘mirroring’ it. There are exceptions (sitting and standing in unison with the priest, for instance). For the most part, this can be explained by the fact that the laity are simply not doing exactly what the priest is doing. They don’t have a host or a chalice in front of them at the elevation, so they don’t elevate anything, and so on.
By Catholic Answers’ count, the ‘orans posture’ is used 28 times during the (Novus Ordo) Mass. There has been widespread controversy about the faithful mirroring it at exactly one of these 28 times. Maybe there are times and places where the faithful mimic it more than that one time, but I haven’t heard much about it; evidently, they’re much rarer.
So why does it happen in this case? At that one time out of the 28, the faithful are expressly told to say (or sing) exactly what the priest is saying (or singing), namely, the Lord’s Prayer. They are speaking in unison with him, rather than listening and responding with Sed libera nos a malo or, as occurs with the Collect, ‘Amen’ (at which time he uses the exact same orans posture). Is it any surprise, then, that if they’re supposed to be saying just what he says, and they’re looking him right in the eyes, they will then (consciously or unconsciously) start doing what he does? Isn’t that just human nature?
The fact that an official rubric requests something directly contrary to what’s natural and intuitive for humans is quite silly. This is not a case where human nature is fallen and we need to work against it; all the principles of human intuition at work here are entirely in accord with right reason.
So the bishops and even the Vatican can clarify all they like (as they did in a 1997 statement) that “neither may deacons or non-ordained members of the faithful use gestures or actions which are proper to the same priest celebrant.” But that hardly fixes the clash with human nature itself found within the rubrics. No amount of clarifications will help the fact that the faithful are “not sure what to do with [our] hands” (as the meme goes).
The bimillennial Western tradition is wiser in this regard: the celebrant faces away from the people, so that they are not picking up cues from him, and he alone recites or chants the Lord’s Prayer, at the end of which the servers, or all the faithful at High Mass, respond: Sed libera nos a malo. This preserves the recitation/response model that is customary throughout the Mass.
Didacus of Alcalá (1400-63) came from a poor but pious family in Spain. He is known to us today as a saint from the (communal) Franciscan Order, his first aspirations were to be a hermit. He embraced the hermit’s life as a child, placing himself under the spiritual guidance of a hermit who lived not far away. And when he was old enough, he became a wandering hermit.
Portrait of St Didacus, 1651-53, by the Spanish painter Francisco de Zurbarán (1598-1664).
But after a while, Didacus felt a calling to the religious life. He entered the Observant (or Reformed) branch of the Order of Friars Minor in Albaida and was sent to the friary in Arruzafa, where he was received as a lay brother. A lay brother was a member of a religious community who did not pray in choir or prepare for holy orders. Lay brothers did most of the manual labor in a community while their better-educated brethren focused on liturgy, preaching, and leadership. For Didacus that meant working at various trades to support the friary.
Spaniards and the Guanche people on the Canary Islands.
The Canary Islands, located about sixty miles off the coast of North Africa, had recently been conquered by Spain, and the Franciscans wished to bring the Gospel to the native Guanche people. Didacus was among the first missionaries to set foot on the islands. In 1445, he was appointed as Guardian of the Franciscan community on Fuerteventura. It was unheard of to make a “mere” lay brother the Superior of a community, but Didacus stood out for his holiness and prudence. He was also passionate about justice. His defense of the Guanche against the genocidal practices of the colonizers forced his return to Spain in 1449.
After a brief stay in Rome helping victims of an epidemic, Didacus spent the rest of his life in the friary of Santa María de Jesús in Alcalá. After his death, his body is believed to have remained incorrupt, not undergoing rigor mortis and emitting a pleasant odor.
Two posthumous miracles seem to corroborate this belief. During a hunting trip, King Henry IV of Castile fell from his horse and injured his arm. After doctors failed to alleviate the intense pain, the king prayed to Didacus for a cure. The Saint’s body was then removed from its coffin and placed next to the king. Henry kissed the body and placed Didacus’ hand on his injured arm. Instantly, it was healed.
Henry IV of Castile
Second, Don Carlos of Asturias fell down a flight of stairs after a night of carousing and landed on his head. Partially paralyzed, blind, and feverish, he asked to make a petition to Didacus. The Saint’s body was brought to the prince and the prior placed the prince’s hand on Didacus’ chest. Carlos fell into a deep sleep, had a dream in which Didacus told him he would be alright, and awoke healed.
If “Saint Didacus” does not sound familiar, perhaps you know the Spanish version better: “San Diego.” California’s second-most populous city received its name when Sebastián Vizcaíno (1550-1629), commanding the ships San Diego, Santo Tomás, and Tres Reyes, landed on the shores of the San Diego Bay on November 12, 1602, and had Mass said in honor of St. Didacus, even though Didacus’ feast day is on November 13. After the Mass, Vizcaíno named the bay after the Saint.
But whether Didacus is the Latin version of Diego remains disputed. All we know is that when Rome canonized the man, they named him Didacus from didache, the Greek word for teaching and the name of one of the earliest books about Christianity. [1] Apparently, the Congregation reviewing Diego’s holiness was so impressed that they considered him to be an embodiment of the ideals of primitive Christian doctrine. And thus the name Didacus/Diego was transferred from a book to a man to a bay to a city.
Note
[1] A complete copy of the Didache was not found until 1873, but Rome since the fifteenth century had a copy of the third-century commentary on the Didache, the Didascalia Apostolorum, and thus the Congregation was aware of the book’s existence and some of its content.
A well-produced video of the nearly-hour-long concert of chant and polyphony in honor of St. Francis of Assisi, performed at the FSSP oratory dedicated to him in Lincoln, Nebraska, is now up on YouTube, with running translations of these most unusual pieces. I encourage you to listen, enjoy, and explore the repertoire. A few of these pieces probably haven’t been heard for decades, even centuries:
The program:
00:00 Uppon La Re Mi ~ Thomas Preston 03:54 The Cloak with the Stars ~ Carson Cooman 08:59 O Sanctissima Anima ~ plainchant 10:00 St. Francis Divests Himself of All Worldly Wealth ~ Carson Cooman 13:19 Proles de Cælo ~ Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina 20:50 Alleluia Franciscus pauper ~ plainchant 23:56 Beatus Franciscus ~ Jerónimo de Aliseda 28:32 Blessed Francis, Holy Father ~ Dom Gregory Murray, O.S.B. 31:08 St. Francis and the Sermon to the Birds ~ Carson Cooman 34:23 O Virum Mirabilem ~ Peter Philips 37:54 Pavane ~ François Poulenc 42:04 Audit in Evangelio ~ Tommaso Graziani 45:38 Salve Sancte Pater ~ plainchant 46:36 Salve Sancte Pater ~ Costanzo Porta 48:47 La François ~ Michel Corrette
The Institute of Catholic Culture is pleased to announce a live webinar with His Eminence Raymond Cardinal Burke to help the faithful prepare for the Solemnity of the Immaculate Conception and the Feast of Our Lady of Guadalupe.
Cardinal Burke will present the lecture titled “Mary’s Maternal Mission: Our Lady of Guadalupe as Co-Redemptrix.” While
controversial, the Marian title of Co-Redemptrix enlightens our own mission to cooperate with Christ’s work of
redemption.
The live lecture will take place over Zoom on Wednesday, December 2nd at 8 pm Eastern time. It is free and open to the
public. Registration is required at instituteofcatholicculture.org.
Our Lady’s apparitions to St. Juan Diego in 1531 offer a vivid expression of Marian theology. They manifest Mary’s maternal
mission to bring Christ’s mercy, healing, and salvation to all peoples. They also help us to properly situate the title of Mary as
Co-Redemptrix, pointing us to Her unique cooperation in the saving mission of her divine Son. Devotion to Our Lady of
Guadalupe, therefore, should strengthen fidelity to Christ, encourage consecration to Mary as a path to Him, and inspire all the
baptized to unite their suffering, service, and witness with Christ for the salvation of the world.
The Institute of Catholic Culture is an adult faith formation organization dedicated to the re-evangelization of our society
through educational and cultural opportunities offered to the public at no charge.